Download Gallery – Hinduism

A Challenge To The Divinity Of Bhagawatgeeta - The Holy book of Hindus

A Challenge To The Divinity Of Bhagawatgeeta – The Holy book of Hindus

Geeta – The Song Of Man

Click here to download

The book critically analyzes the divinity of Bhagawatgeeta by presenting a series of inconsistencies, errors and contradictions present in it. Of course, alternate opinions are welcome. All are welcome to refute or defend the works of the author (that would be me) and the author would only be pleased. But this book must not be taken as an excuse to hate. The ultimate goal that the author dreamt before writing the book was peace and conciliation between Hindus and Muslims by making them aware of the truth about God and his actual divine book.
Advertisements

21 responses to “Download Gallery – Hinduism

  1. When AR Rehman received the Oscars he said the following in his acceptance speech :

    In life I always had two choices – to hate or to Love.I chose Love.

    It is noteworthy that he changed his religion from Hinduism to Muslim as he became a devotee of a Sufi saint.Yet the entire Indian population 80% of whom are Hindus love him as their very own.This is why I feel that India is an emotionally and mentally evolved nation.
    None of us have met either Krishna,Allah or Jesus and this whole attitude of Holier than thou has landed the world especially muslims in such a big mess.
    I am sorry to say but I found the approach very childish – My toy is better than your toy type.
    If you are really interested in understanding the depth of thought in The Bhagwad Geeta pls read the interpretation by Swami Chinmayananda or Dr Radhakrishnan.If it is Gods word you need a higher level of evolution to understand it.That is if you are really interested in knowing the truth.Else I agree with you that Quran is Gods word and it is the greatest.Happy?
    For God sake stop thinking the way you have been.Will not take you anywhere.Awareness is beyond words and it comes only to a heart that is full of love and compassion.
    Even before you think about realizing God,ask yourself if you are a good at least a Good Human.
    May Allah show you the right path.(you already believe that Krishna is incapable of doing so)

  2. @ aahang – i understand that you are a very broad minded and wise person. You have the insight to respect other peoples culture and beliefs and for this i am really glad. I too respect the beliefs of other people but there is a slight difference here. I don’t over exaggerate this respect to extremes and present it as “more than life” manner like how most people do.

    The work “Geeta – The song of man” is a research work. So if you arent satisfied with it or if you have any differences with it then the ONLY and ONLY way to sort it out is to DISPROVE OR REFUTE each and every claim that i have made in it by giving me scriptural proofs. ie proof from Geeta itself.

    The statements that you have made is as good as someone giving a lecture on conserving nature to a thief instead of proving or disproving his theft. Are these two related in any way?

    As far as me reading the interpretations of Swami Chinmayananda or Dr Radhakrishnan to know the depth of Geeta, let me tell you this : – I do not go by the rules of any man who isn’t certified by God or any religious book to understand the book. Why should i take the help of two ordinary mortals to understand something which is from God? Are you trying to tell me that God’s books are so tough that only super intelligent beings can understand them?
    For me, of all the books of laws in the world, the easiest should be the books of God. God never sends cryptic or esoteric messages to mankind because he knows that he hasn’t created all of us with super intelligence. All his messages are plain, simple, easily understandable and easily implementable. This is common sense.

    If you want to glorify esoteric, emotional and cryptic statements as “the word of God” at the cost of logic, reasoning and science then you are welcome to do so. All the best.

  3. I am sure you have read “The Satanic Verses” by Salman Rushdie.If it is his own interpretation of Quran why did the whole Mulim world go after him issuing a Fatwa.
    If you had just said that I am unable to understand the context or contradiction then someone could have taken the time to explain it to you but you already believe that you know the truth so there is no point.Your tone is demeaning ,not something that one expects from a seeker of truth whatever you may call it.
    As far as Logic and science are concerned you will benefit by reading Albert Einstien’s views on God.He declared that the mystery of creation and our existence is too complex for him to understand.And we certainly are lesser mortals than him.
    In Vedas it is said “Tarkasya Apratishtha” which simply means that logic never prevails and as a student of science you would know how almost all scientific ideas have been challenged even dumped as new ones have been discovered Ex Newtonian Laws were refuted by Einstien’s theory of relativity.
    Hate and Science will take this far only.I would encourage you to have a more liberal view of the world and free your spirit to discover for itself what is right,it does not matter what the path is but it must take you to the supreme reality – I call it Krishna and you call it Allah.
    May peace be with you,always.

  4. I really appreciate your views about having liberal views of the world and the reason is because i myself do have them. But your views on science and logic can be improved. If you believe that blind beliefs which most people erroneously term as “faith” are to be given more importance than established science and logical reasoning then feel free to do it. But i believe that the greatest scientist is “GOD”. I see or i know God through science and logic. I do agree and i do appreciate and i do believe that spirituality is an integral part of belief in God. But science and spirituality goes hand in hand for a Muslim. If you are taught to believe that science and God are something different then it is very unfortunate. Perhaps this explains why there are so many contradictions in the Geeta or why not even one person has come forward with a refutation to the work “Geeta – the song of man”

  5. The Cynic in you never rests.Does it ?
    As far as refutation of Geeta is concerned – If I proove to you that everything said in it has a context and is therefore true and the word of God,you will be in big problem.Because then you will have to let loose of Muhammad as he the only prophet and Allah is the only God.As far as I am concerned I already believe that there is Allah the merciful and Krishna the Playful.
    If you really believe that there is one God and someone can convince you through similar reasoning as you have given taking pieces from here and there in the book to make a point,are you willing to give up Islam.
    Have you ever thought that one reason that no one has bothered could be that they found your pursuit childish ?Think about it.
    Let’s Give up this debate now.If you see my blog I love Sufism and my favorite Quwallis are in praise of Allah even though I am a hindu.All I am saying is that you are missing out on something that is good by keeping a narrow view point.
    Ek lafz e mohabbat ka adna ye fasaana hai
    simte to dil e aashiq phaile to Zamaana hai.
    I will leave the choice to you.
    I am sure both allah and krishna are smiling at us.If nothing else they are capable of protecting their own reputations 🙂

  6. Guy DeWhitney

    You declare that you ” see or … know God through science and logic”
    Can you give me a quick example of the Qur’an speaking of quantum mechanics in ways not tracable to other religion’s (Hindu, Buddhist, Judaic, Greek, etc…) of earlier periods?
    It has pretty much been proven IN THE LABORATORY By EXPERIMENT that all the universe is one thing, a concept central to most Eastern religions long before Islam appeared. Give me an example that does NOT appear in the Gita or other pre-500CE texts?
    I note that you also say you are liberal of mind, would you care to give examples of what YOU consider “liberal” thinking?

  7. I thought someone forwarded my threat to the FBI. So u mean to say that u wud “consider” believing in the Quran if i show u something about Quantum mechanics? are u sure? are u sure that u wudnt cookup another excuse and say “show me this .. show me that …only then i wud beliv”. think about it.

    havent anyone told you that Quran is not what u call a reference book for Quantum mechanics?

    It is a book of religion which makes use of science to drive things into thick skulls of humans

    You cant just declare “I will beliv in the Quran only if it tells me something about the string theory or the loop – gravity theory” etc. By having such attitude u are only narrowing ur choices.

    my suggestion – before making demands read atleast some .. if not all of science related stuff present in the quran. for a start u cud read some from this blog itself.
    article 1

    article 2

    article 3

    article 4 part 1

    article r part 2

    article 5

    article 6

    article 7

    and oh.. yeah hindusim does give a clear picture of how universe was created. step by step and class graphical. You see there was this great man like thing long ago .. from his eyes comes the sun ..from his nose came the moon.. from his skin grew the trees like hair… and something important comes from his rear end too..- check out the upanishads. so u see.. we do have a big bang theory here wherein all things were united in that big thing before each of the cosmic things came out of his body.. u want to go publicise this as proof that this supports the big bang theory?

    and mmmm… unlike you i condemn Israeli aggression and massacres on Palestine. If Palestine and Israeli were to switch roles then i wud condemn Palestine too I think this example should be enough to show my liberalness…



    www.truecall.com

  8. Guy DeWhitney

    *… GuyWhitney’s blahs…*

    I was showing that you cannot find a scrap of anything to support your theology in modern science.
    Let me put it this way, if everything in teh universe is ONE thing, then your Allah cannot be separate from it as the Qur’an claims (and the Bible for that matter)!

  9. @ GuyDeWhitney

    GuyDeWhitney – I was showing that you cannot find a scrap of anything to support your theology in modern science

    Oh yeah i do and i dont need to shove the scraps of what i have to appease u. there is enough of it everywhere. go find it urselves if u want to.

    u said – Let me put it this way, if everything in teh universe is ONE thing, then your Allah cannot be separate from it as the Qur’an claims (and the Bible for that matter)!

    who the hell are you to decide this? God?? or a noble prize winning scientist? stop behaving as if u ve done some great research in physics and universe and have come to the conclusion that “God can be or cannot be separate from the universe” Learn to just go with whatever proofs u have and dont jump to radical conclusions such as these. this only shows how un- liberal u are.


    listen to Quran and its meaning

  10. Guy DeWhitney

    ““If Palestine and Israeli were to switch roles then i wud condemn Palestine too I think this example should be enough to show my liberalness…”

    About all it shows is how tribalistic you are.

    Me – The only way that is not a lie as far as I can see from your threats and libelous retorts is that you define “switch roles” to mean that the Palestinians would then be Jewish and the Israelis Muslim!

    Prove me wrong; in clear terms condemn for us ANY living Muslim for any heinous act they might have commited in YOUR eyes!
    Can you do it?

  11. yeah i absolutely can do it. take salman rushdie for the matter or gengiz kahn (THE famous gengiz kahn)…. mmm osama bin laden …then lemme see.. all his cronies in the hundreds..the terrorists of pakistan and india too…then we have the lashkar and oh al – queda … i condemn all of these. i hope u arent dumb enough to ask who all these people are.

    and oh.. by switching roles i meant ROLE on Battle field u dumb ass and not religion. as in the MUSLIM Palestine driving away Jewish israel and flattening out their homes with state of art US sponsored weaponry and constructing concrete walls and lining up Jewish women and children for target practice while all along poor Jewish Israel retorts with home made rockets if available or with evergreen stones if rockets arent available. If this was the scene i would still condemn the MUSLIM PALESTINE and support the JEWISH ISRAEL cause..

    as for your rest of comments i am trashing them as they arent worth replying – senseless without a head or tail as usual. hey i guess u hold a record here at my blog – the guy with the most trashed comments. Keep up the gud work!

  12. Guy DeWhitney

    LOL, riiight, I notice you missed Hamas there, no condemnation for the group that has a charter declaring theri intent to do what you just claimed you oppose, drive Israel into oblivion…
    Hmm, care to elaborate? And WHAT is it that you condemn those mentioned FOR? Specifically please…

  13. yeah u noticed it right… i do condemn all unjust acts of aggression done by anyone whether it is Muslims or christians or hamas or whatever ( now dont come whining like a kid saying i missed out hinduism here .. ooo u are sooo triablistic etc etc).

    you said -Hmm, care to elaborate? And WHAT is it that you condemn those mentioned FOR? Specifically please…

    am i a News channel for u? Dude take a hike. go turn on CNN or whatever ..( God i missed out BBC and Al-Jazeera – I am so news tribalistic!.. ooops sorry channelistic! )

  14. Guy DeWhitney

    I do imagine you are a bit biased in your news sources; I get my spectrum of data from (in part): Haaretz, al-jazeera, jerusalem Post, al-arabiya, Isvestia & Pravda, BBC, CBS, Fox, CNN, C-Span, Huffington Post and the David Horowitz group of blogs…I no longer WRITE for NewsRal Blog since the editor David Swindle decided I was too ready to attack idiots on the far right that were acting tribal and partisan as well as the ones on the Left.

    That said, Wow, you are slippery, you really do not want to give a clear answer do you?

    Let me make it easy if not painless for you. Just give simple, basic answers regarding the following; I do not think you can. Just try to force youreself to remember that more no than yes is a no, and more yes than no is a yes; these are not questions that a civilized person shoud have to think abot for a moment:

    Do you desire to see the Shari’a applied in lands that are not Muslim governed already?
    Yes, or No?

    Do you feel it is just for a Muslim to kill a non-Muslim for persecution (of the Muslim BY the non-Muslim) that falls short of violence or its actual threat? Yes, or No?

    Do you consider ALL people not actively in uniformed service to their country as civilians? Yes or No?

    Do you condemn ANYONE who kills ANY children deliberately?
    Yes or No?

    Stop tossng in weasel words like unjust and innocent. Civilians are civilians, you should not need to qualify it.

    Oh, and of course you trash my comments, yo have no answer to them that even you can pretend will sound sensible…You choose to censor me to try to gain an unfair advantage in the debate but all you do is show yourself to anyone not already brainwashed that you are a disengenuous-minded barbarian who doesn’t even understand the civiliation he desires to rape. Since yo seem to need to answer me I guews you feel I have points that need to be SEEN to be refuted, apparently even at the cost of appearing arrogant and as slippery as a politician caught screwing the mailman to anyone not already singing in your choir, so to speak.
    I also have the ability to save my comments and repost them, with your idiocy attached, on MY blog! Oh, someone in te U.S. Senate just viewed my poem again, it is realy getting popular!

  15. I really dont understand what ur problem in life is. May be ur problem is that u think all religious people are herectics. u really want to know why u are getting this attitude and treatment from me? Its because u refuse to acknowledge the injustice that is happening in middle east to the Palestinians which is a PRESENT DAY ONGOING crysis. FULL STOP

    So to answer ur questions

    Guydewhitney – Do you desire to see the Shari’a applied in lands that are not Muslim governed already? Yes, or No?

    Obviously No. sharia is not to be applied to Lands that are not governed by muslims. Dude this is common sense… ( aaah i am so barbaric – the barbaric arab animal eh) But u guys wouldnt mind imposing ur rules and customs in lands such as lets say palestine afghanisthan etc etc right.. ( so cute)

    Guydewhitney – Do you feel it is just for a Muslim to kill a non-Muslim for persecution (of the Muslim BY the non-Muslim) that falls short of violence or its actual threat? Yes, or No?

    Dude get a good dictionary. does anyone get persecuted in a non violent and non threatening way? lol! dont be so confused in life. anyway, If the persecution falls short of violene or actual threat no muslim is alowed to kill. But if the persecution involves driving the concerned muslim from his home + settling in his land and property + killing maybe 2-3 family members of his + cutting his food and medical supplies + destroying his/her peaceful home sweet home life and left to live in make shift camps without schools proper toilete etc etc then hell yeah …..YEAH .. hey can u ask ur wife or ur girlfriend or mom whether it is ok to kill someone in these circimstances? Oh i forgot…. u call these guys as terrorists right?

    Guydewhitney – Do you consider ALL people not actively in uniformed service to their country as civilians? Yes or No?

    depends.. now from where and why did this come into ur head?

    Guydewhitney – Do you condemn ANYONE who kills ANY children deliberately? Yes or No?

    ofcourse I do.. unlike YOU who so stiff neckedly refuse to let out a single sigh of sympathy to the children deliberately killed by Israeli US or whatever soldiers. for the record.. if any palestinian kills an israeli child i wud condemn him too. Unlike you, I wudnt start giving lame excuses and tom dick n harry’s un historic quotes to justify the killings

    Guydewhitney – Oh, and of course you trash my comments, yo have no answer to them that even you can pretend will sound sensible…You choose to censor me to try to gain an unfair advantage in the debate but all you do is show yourself to anyone not already brainwashed that you are a disengenuous-minded barbarian who doesn’t even understand the civiliation he desires to rape. Since yo seem to need to answer me I guews you feel I have points that need to be SEEN to be refuted, apparently even at the cost of appearing arrogant and as slippery as a politician caught screwing the mailman to anyone not already singing in your choir, so to speak.
    I also have the ability to save my comments and repost them, with your idiocy attached, on MY blog! Oh, someone in te U.S. Senate just viewed my poem again, it is realy getting popular!

    Omg ur whinning started! It seems that i really tickled you.. Heck am enjoying this so much. and ooooooo am so scared… mommy where are u….

  16. Guy DeWhitney

    “i meant ROLE on Battle field u dumb ass and not religion. as in the MUSLIM Palestine driving away Jewish israel and flattening out their homes with state of art …weaponry .
    So you condemn the Arabs for attacking Israel in 47 and 48 then? Good I am glad to hear you believe that Israel did not “deserve” to be attacked by forces that far outnumberd and out-gunned them..lol, I always get a kick out of that, just remembering with all that advantage and aggression, they still got their asses handed to them in return for defying international law, custom and basic human decency.
    Or do you want to go back to 1850 and lay outy a timeline to show that most of the “Palestinian” narrative is fantasy?
    I do not recommend it, I have quotes, do you?

    “Who can challenge the rights of the Jews in Palestine? Good Lord,
    historically it is really your country.” Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi,
    Mayor of Jerusalem,1899.

    “It is manifestly right that the scattered Jews should have a national center and a national home and be reunited, and where else but in Palestine, with which for 3,000 years they have been intimately and
    profoundly associated?” Winston Churchill, 1920

    “Of the total of 418,000 dunums (quarter-acres) acquired by Jews in Palestine [between 1878 and 1914], 58 percent was sold by non-Palestinian [Arab] absentee landlords and 36 percent by Palestinian
    absentee landlords, for a total of 94 percent.”
    —Palestinian-American historian Rashid Khalidi

    “Palestine is a term the Zionists invented!…Our country for centuries was part of Syria.”
    —Local Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi, to the Peel Commission in 1937.

    “Those good Jews brought…prosperity over Palestine without damage to anyone or taking anything by force.” —Syrian Alawi notable’s letter to French Prime Minister, June 1936

    “No one doubted that the Arabs had benefitted from Jewish immigration. Their numbers had almost doubled between 1917 and 1940, wages had gone up, the standard of living had risen more than anywhere else
    in the Middle East.” —Historian Walter Laqueur

    “The Arab states do not want to solve the refugee problem. They want to keep it an open sore, as an affront to the UN and as a weapon against Israel.” —Ralph Galloway, former Director of UNRWA, August 1958

    “All the Arab countries want to keep this problem looking like an open
    wound.” —Ana Liria-Franch, regional representative in Cairo for the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, 2003 16

    “If Arabs return to Israel—Israel will cease to exist.”
    —Gamal Abdel Nasser, President of Egypt, 1961

    Had enough yet?

  17. Guydewhitney – So you condemn the Arabs for attacking Israel
    Or do you want to go back to 1850 and lay outy a timeline to show that most of the “Palestinian” narrative is fantasy?

    I do not recommend it, I have quotes, do you?

    Put a frame on these quotes and hang them on ur porch. These are perfect Peace spreading angelic beauties.

    Guydewhitney – “Who can challenge the rights of the Jews in Palestine? Good Lord, historically it is really your country.” Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, Mayor of Jerusalem,1899.

    Guydewhitney – “It is manifestly right that the scattered Jews should have a national center and a national home and be reunited, and where else but in Palestine, with which for 3,000 years they have been intimately and profoundly associated?” Winston Churchill, 1920

    I have no god – damn idea what u believ in. you cant just say this land belongs to them and that land belongs to them etc. I know you have gone ga ga over these quotes. If i go by these quotes then Australia originally belongs to the Aborigines, America belongs to the red indians, India to the dravidians and South africa to the african natives. So if these native guys suddenly come knocking one fine day and settle in their native lands BY DRIVING AWAY THE LOCALs ( watch out – you may be one of the locals) is it fine? Dont you see what is happeneing here? How different is this scene from what is happening in Middle east? This is what i believe: – This land.. this earth belongs to all human beings. If I had the authority and power i would make them all live side by side with whatever faith they choose. yeah with people like u around this seems to be a fantasy.

    guydewhitney – (gosh i forgot to capitalize ur name.. did u see that?)

    “Those good Jews brought…prosperity over Palestine without damage to anyone or taking anything by force.” —Syrian Alawi
    notable’s letter to French Prime Minister, June 1936

    “No one doubted that the Arabs had benefitted from Jewish immigration. Their numbers had almost doubled between 1917 and 1940, wages had gone up, the standard of living had risen more than anywhere else
    in the Middle East.” —Historian Walter Laqueur

    OMG dude… this is heights of foolishness .. After all this are u trying to say that what Israel is doing right now is bringing peace AND what was that – oh prosperity! to the palestinians? somebody stop me i cant control laughing.

    guydewhitney – “The Arab states do not want to solve the refugee problem. They want to keep it an open sore, as an affront to the UN and as a weapon against Israel.” —Ralph Galloway, former Director of UNRWA, August 1958

    “All the Arab countries want to keep this problem looking like an open wound.” —Ana Liria-Franch, regional representative in
    Cairo for the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, 2003 16

    Had enough yet?

    Nope – unlike you i still retain my senses. you say u have 30 years of experience.. i guess u are twice as old as me. Pretty disappointing performance and yeah… I have no idea what the Arabs are doing. But whatever they are doing apparently it isnt helping either them or anyone else.

    “If Arabs return to Israel—Israel will cease to exist.” — Gamal Abdel Nasser, President of Egypt, 1961

    see.. this is what i mean. you guys are so stereotypic and dogmatic that you wudnt think twice of labelling an entire race as barbaric. I challenge you openly to show me one place in this blog where i have said jews are barbaric as a whole. where ever i have spoken it is always ISRAEL – a political country and NOT JEWISM – a religion.. oh please dont pick things out of context and come with a stupid grin with some sentenses picked from this blog.

    Anyway i ve seen these stupid quotes of yours being bashed by many people word to word. I didnt want to spoil the surprize.

    I love those jews, christians, muslims, hindus, atheiists and whomsoever it is who gives a damn about some things like justice, peace and harmony. Now am sure you wud come after my throat pointing out the various anti other religious stuff posted here. Just to let you know they are for spiritual, theological and academic interests. Did you see the notice board posted on EVERY PAGE of this blog – on the right side in the narrow pane in blue bold font?
    It is this :-

    A common forum for all to brag about their beliefs with reason, logic, science and of course love. Haters whether you are Muslim, Christian. Jew or Hindu, pleaze get out immediately!

  18. I seek refuge of Allah from Satan the evil….
    In The Name Of Allah Most Gracious Most Merciful…
    from surah 21
    95:
    But there is a ban on any population which We have destroyed: that they
    shall not return.

    96:
    Until the Gog and Magog (people) are let through (their barrier) and they
    swiftly swarm from every hill.

  19. The next session of discussion between me and this dewhitney guy is too interesting to post here. So i decided to have it as a separate post. Please find it here: –

    https://prophetrejectors.wordpress.com/2010/05/30/the-truth-about-israel-and-palestine/

  20. Can you please send me the book – Geeta – the song of man. Unable to download it from your site -its saying ‘file not found’ .. jazakallah.

  21. Sir,the book ” Gita,the song of Man” can’t be downloaded . The site says it stopped the service. Can you pls send me a copy ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s